Team Trella Maui
Team Trella Maui
  • Home
  • Appraisals
  • Sales
  • Featured Properties
  • Management
  • RESOURCES
    • Attorney & CPA Appraisals
    • Buyer's Guide
    • Seller's Guide
    • Moving to Maui with Pets
    • Testimonials
  • More
    • Home
    • Appraisals
    • Sales
    • Featured Properties
    • Management
    • RESOURCES
      • Attorney & CPA Appraisals
      • Buyer's Guide
      • Seller's Guide
      • Moving to Maui with Pets
      • Testimonials
  • Home
  • Appraisals
  • Sales
  • Featured Properties
  • Management
  • RESOURCES
    • Attorney & CPA Appraisals
    • Buyer's Guide
    • Seller's Guide
    • Moving to Maui with Pets
    • Testimonials

Appraisal Offerings & Areas of Expertise

We provide independent real property appraisal services across Maui County, including Maui, Lānaʻi, and Molokaʻi. Assignments range from lending and private use appraisals to complex legal, tax, and insurance‑related matters.

Financing Appraisals

  • Conventional financing
  • Hard money and private money loans
  • Refinancing
  • FHA and VA loans

Private & Pre‑Purchase Appraisals – Maui County

Appraisals prepared for buyers, investors, and private transactions where a lender is not involved.


These assignments are commonly requested for:

  • Pre‑purchase (“pre‑appraisal”) decisions before making an offer
  • Off‑market transactions between private parties
  • Cash purchases without lender requirements
  • Situations where a buyer wants an independent opinion of value prior to closing


An independent appraisal can help establish a credible market value benchmark, support negotiation, and reduce uncertainty in transactions where no lender appraisal is required.


Assignments are developed based on the intended use and timing of the transaction, and may be coordinated with buyers, agents, or other professionals as appropriate.


For appraisals prepared specifically for legal, probate, or litigation matters, see Attorney & CPA Appraisals.

Estate & Legal‑Related Appraisals

  • Date‑of‑Death (Time‑of‑Death) Appraisals
  • Estate Planning Appraisals
  • Dissolution of Partnerships, including divorces and partnership buyouts
  • Disaster and Insurance‑Related Appraisals, including loss documentation and valuation for insurance claims and litigation


For appraisals prepared specifically for attorneys, CPAs, and fiduciaries, see Attorney & CPA Appraisals.

Property Tax Valuation Appeals – Maui County

Appraisals prepared to support appeals of County of Maui assessed property values for real property tax purposes.


These assignments are commonly used to:

  • Challenge County‑assessed valuations that exceed market value
  • Support formal real property tax appeals
  • Provide independent market value opinions for assessment review


Appraisals are prepared with the applicable valuation date and appeal standards in mind and may be coordinated with property owners, attorneys, or tax professionals.

Complex & Specialized Assignments

  • Complex or atypical properties
  • Properties with unique characteristics or limited comparable data
  • Assignments requiring expanded analysis and documentation

Litigation Support & Expert Services

  • Expert appraisal reports prepared for legal matters
  • Consultation with attorneys and other professionals
  • Expert testimony, when required

About the Appraiser

John Trella is a Certified Real Estate Appraiser in the State of Hawaiʻi with 27 years of experience. He provides independent, well‑supported appraisals prepared with clear scope definition and intended use in mind.


To request a quote, engagement letter, or to add John Trella to your appraisal panel, please contact:

john@johntrella.com  |  808.799.4271

Important Disclosure

Our appraisal business is not affiliated with or associated with Coldwell Banker Island Properties.

Frequently Asked Questions

If your question relates to a specific property, assignment type, or intended use, please contact John at 808.799.4271 to discuss scope and requirements.

An appraisal is a licensed appraiser’s formal opinion of market value prepared under USPAP standards and used for lending, tax, estate, and legal purposes. A home valuation is an informal estimate prepared by a real estate agent and has no legal or lending authority.


An appraisal is required when a formal, defensible opinion of value is needed for lending, tax, estate, insurance, or legal purposes. A broker price opinion (BPO) is an informal estimate and is not accepted by lenders, courts, or taxing authorities.


A Date‑of‑Death appraisal is a retrospective appraisal that determines the market value of real property as of the date an owner passed away. It is commonly used for probate, estate settlement, and establishing a stepped‑up tax basis.


An appraisal uses a specific effective valuation date, which depends on the intended use. This may be the current date, a past date (such as a date‑of‑death), or a statutory assessment date for tax appeals.


Yes. A buyer can request a pre‑purchase appraisal before making an offer to better understand the property’s market value.


This is most common in:

  • Competitive markets
  • Off‑market opportunities
  • Higher‑value or unique properties


A pre‑purchase appraisal provides an independent opinion of value but does not guarantee acceptance of an offer.


A lender does not require an appraisal for a cash purchase, but buyers may still choose to obtain one.


An independent appraisal can help:

  • Confirm market value
  • Support negotiation
  • Reduce risk in the transaction


To prepare for an appraisal:

  • Ensure all areas of the property are accessible
  • Secure pets during the inspection
  • For multi‑unit or tenant‑occupied properties, provide proper notice to occupants
  • Prepare a list of recent improvements, including dates, costs, and permits (if applicable)
  • For condominiums, provide HOA contact information


Providing complete and accurate information helps ensure an efficient appraisal process.


No. An appraisal estimates market value, while a home inspection evaluates physical condition. Appraisers observe condition as it affects value but do not perform the detailed systems analysis provided by a licensed home inspector.


Yes. An appraisal may be used to support an appeal of a County of Maui assessed property value if the assessed value exceeds market value.


Appraisals prepared for tax appeal purposes:

  • Are developed for the applicable valuation date
  • Address market value specifically for assessment review
  • May be used by property owners, attorneys, or tax professionals during the appeal process


An appraisal does not guarantee a tax reduction, but it provides an independent, well‑supported opinion of value.


No. An appraisal report prepared for lending, estate, or private use is not automatically provided to the County of Maui or local tax authorities.


Only appraisals voluntarily submitted as part of a property tax appeal are reviewed for assessment purposes.


  • If a lender orders the appraisal, the lender owns the report but must provide a copy to the borrower upon request.
  • If a homeowner or client directly hires the appraiser, the client owns the report and controls how it may be used and shared.


Ownership and intended use are defined in the engagement agreement.


Most appraisal inspections take approximately 30 minutes. Larger homes, complex properties, or multi‑unit properties may require additional time.


Market value is primarily influenced by overall market conditions, but owners can improve presentation and condition by:

  • Maintaining the home in good repair
  • Updating kitchens and bathrooms where appropriate
  • Improving curb appeal through landscaping and exterior maintenance


An appraiser reflects market reaction to these factors but does not assign value based on cost alone.


Online valuation tools rely on automated data and cannot account for the unique characteristics, condition, or location factors of individual properties.


Only a licensed or certified real estate appraiser can provide a credible, defensible opinion of value suitable for lending, tax, estate, or legal use.


Yes. Appraisals are often used in off‑market or private transactions to establish a neutral, independent opinion of value.


This is common when:

  • There is no public listing history
  • Parties want a fair value reference
  • The transaction involves family, partners, or direct negotiation


Maui County is a unique and complex real estate market, including Maui, Lānaʻi, and Molokaʻi.


A Certified Real Estate Appraiser has:

  • Advanced education and experience
  • No limits on property value or assignment complexity
  • Geographic competency specific to the local market


Local experience helps ensure accuracy, credibility, and proper market interpretation.


Copyright © 2026 teamtrella - All Rights Reserved.

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept